Governance HIV infected hemophilia patients claim 3 Foshan 6,000,000
Time: 2009-07-21
Prosecution by the Shanghai Institute of Biological Products Chancheng District Court, the patient convinced that produced without the use of the drug to inactivated HIV infected blood coagulation factor VIII






In 1982, developed by the Health and factor VIII preparations, a large number of hemophiliacs have been used nationwide. (/ Figure Chen Zhigang photo)



Core tips

Lack of blood coagulation in patients with von Willebrand factor (factor VIII mainly), the need for supplementary intravenous regular basis, or else can not stop bleeding. 1982, on the Health of the developed freeze-dried human clotting factor Ⅷ (hereinafter referred to as "factor VIII") preparation and production, has been a large number of hemophiliacs nationwide vaccination, but in 1998 after hundreds of the country, emerging Friends of the blood of patients with HIV infection, in the exclusion of mother to child transmission and sexually transmitted, they look suspicious to the regular injection of Health for use by the removal of inactivated virus did not deal with the eight factors.

10 years ago in the treatment of hemophilia patients infected with AIDS, many people can not afford the high cost of treatment, has died. There are some patients being brought up by Health.

By the end of April this year, Foshan AIDS to small Bo Shanghai Biological Products Institute (hereinafter referred to as "by the Health") brought to the Court. In his view, the treatment of hemophilia in the process without the use of detoxification by Health inactivated clotting factor products that lead to HIV infection, the prosecution of more than 200 million claims, and by May 6 Chancheng district court file.

After Foshan two patients with the same prosecution has been in Chancheng District Court case, the continuation of the National Health Institute of domino action. Before and after, Jiangxi, Heilongjiang, Hunan and other places there have been nearly 10 similar case prosecuted by local courts. In other parts of the country, there are still dozens of patients with difficult to file in the local court, they eagerly looking forward to the progress of such cases will be病友们appeal.

However, on June 24 hearing before the court received notice of the small bo - a postponement of the hearing of cases. Similarly, the current number of similar cases nationwide have been delayed or rejected by the prosecution.

July 12, six patients from families all over the country gather in Changsha, emergency consultations on how to pursue the responsibility of Health and to claim compensation.

Trial postponed

Health where the objection to the jurisdiction of the book that the effect is small pouthi damages product quality disputes, tort cases are product quality, in accordance with the law or infringement by the defendant to the jurisdiction of the court house. Health and by the location of the Changning District in Shanghai

Small Bo prosecution by the Health and factor VIII product infringement claim, originally scheduled for June 24 in Chancheng district court.

Foshan Municipal People's Congress expressed concern about the case and sent to the court to attend on the same day only to head the air.

The National People's Congress asked the staff to the court that in June 2, the Health and objections raised by the jurisdiction, to hear the case had to be postponed.

Health where the objection to the jurisdiction of the book that the effect is small pouthi damages product quality disputes, tort cases are product quality, in accordance with the law or infringement by the defendant to the jurisdiction of the court house. Health is located on the Shanghai Changning District, the plaintiff there is no evidence that violations occurred in Chancheng District, so the case should be the jurisdiction of the Court of Changning District, Shanghai.

"Life is precious, the other is obviously the time delay, we can not afford the cost." The father of small Bo Zhao said.

Since October 2003, the Shanghai Changning District Court will not entertain such litigation.

July 7, what a turnaround in the day Chancheng district court ruled that "the case of violations and the results of the implementation of land area in Chancheng" Health is therefore dismissed on jurisdictional objection raised.

Zhao said it is estimated that by the Health and will soon be ruling on this appeal to the court in Foshan city.

According to him, a district in Guangzhou, the same court with the prosecution on the Health of the cases, on the Health of jurisdiction raised by the objection, but rejected by the Court, by the Health has appealed to the Intermediate Court of Guangzhou.

At present, by the Health on the other two patients Foshan litigation, also raised objections to jurisdiction, Chancheng has yet been made whether the district court's decision dismissed.

That the occurrence of high-profile litigation, but also traced back to more than 10 years ago.

Foshan It said three hemophiliacs, they from 1990 to 1996, the progress has been either alone or together with the purchase of Health and the coagulation factor VIII.

From 2001 to 2005, the three patients have been diagnosed Foshan CDC AIDS and hepatitis C infection. In their view, the main way of HIV infection through mother to child transmission, blood-borne, sexually transmitted, but the families of their own parents were not infected with AIDS, their AIDS diagnosis prior to sexual contact, and 3 young people suffering from hemophilia, long-term injection on Health and the eight-factor, the only way to infected blood infection.

November 24, 2008, the National Bureau of letters and a number of similar patients nationwide to respond to the complaint, it is recommended in patients with legitimate claims through the legal channels.

Earlier this year, 3 patients have a number of Foshan to seek counsel cases, but have been rejected. Some lawyers said the case is too many uncertainties, it is recommended in patients with three other similar groups of patients with lawsuits follow a joint path, and to seek the help of deputies.

"Go to the National People's Congress the record, linked to a number," said Zhao. After, 3 patients have to the National People's Congress of Guangdong Province and Foshan Municipal People's Congress delivery information on the case, and one in Guangzhou to recruit lawyers to prosecute.






Xi'an Jia Ping hemophiliacs (wheelchair), was May 30, 2007 death from AIDS. (/ Figure Chen Zhigang photo)

By the end of April this year, Zhao Bo, as son of the agent, to product quality disputes damages, citing the Health一纸诉状将by court. In the complaint, the son of Zhao Wei said AIDS diagnosed in 2001, although there are 8 hours away from the prosecution, but non-stop as a result of their claims through various channels, has not had the time.

May 6, Chancheng District Court found the case file, and arranged for the morning of June 24 hearing. That same month, the prosecution of the other two patients have been Chancheng District Court.

Compensation agreement

Expressed by the Health, based on the 3 patients with high medical costs, the difficulties of life, from a humanitarian point of view, a one-time per patient to be 100,000 yuan relief funds. But at the same time believe that the acts of their own relief, the patient can not be interpreted as legal responsibility for HIV infection

In the pre-indictment, Foshan 3 patients, respectively, and by the Health signed a salvage agreement.

AIDS diagnosis, after three patients and their families to Shanghai many times, to protest against the Shanghai Biological Products Institute, which seeks compensation to the Ministry of Health and other government departments.

April 14 this year, came to represent the Health Foshan, Foshan, 3 patients with negotiations and signed agreements relief.

In that agreement, recognized by the Health, Foshan hemophiliacs 3 patients, who have bought or used their own factor VIII production. But the view that 3 patients can not prove that the direct cause of HIV infection is the use of its own production of the eight factors that 3 patients in the course of treatment, not just the purchase of or used by the Health and factor VIII production.

Expressed by the Health, based on the 3 patients with high medical costs, the difficulties of life, from a humanitarian point of view, a one-time per patient to be 100,000 yuan relief. But at the same time believe that the acts of their own relief, the patient can not be interpreted as legal responsibility for HIV infection. "This agreement payments, as the two sides to resolve disputes in respect of the incident has reached the final."

Zhao Wei, the last of Health also requested by the patient, including the media, not to disclose the agreement of any consultation process and content are no longer patients at the same time for any reason, up Health or related units that seek compensation or further relief, etc. .

"The agreement will not only himself as the savior for the victims and philanthropist, but there should be an attempt to escape civil liability." In the process of consultation, Zhao Wei and Chen patients on the Health of the parents, "the final" presentation strongly opposed, and for a time refused to sign.

After Zhao et al proposed to add the terms, "subject to the receipt of the Health救助者by 100,000 yuan relief assistance payments and the signing of the agreement, related to future national policy and relevant laws and regulations in which the relevant departments to seek help. If through the proceedings, subject to still have and will retain救助者related rights. "

After high-level instructions agreed to by the Health, on behalf of Health and by a supplemental agreement reached with the patients, 3 patients on the same day in the program on Health and the agreement signed. At present, through the Red Cross handed over Foshan, 3 patients have each received 100,000 yuan assistance payments.

It is reported that the Health has worked with dozens of similar patients nationwide to sign the aid agreement, but one patient in Jiangxi Province, signed an agreement last year after the prosecution to the court by filing a case, the patient requests a court decision on their own with the assistance of Health signed an agreement null and void.

Claim 6000000

In November 2005 to April this year, as a result of suffering from AIDS, hepatitis C and haemophilia exacerbations, Zhao son Chancheng hospital district spent a total of 580,000 yuan

"For the treatment of factor VIII by the use of the AIDS infection, we have not only ruined the economy, and in spirit also suffered a heavy blow." Zhao said that upward of Health on behalf of his son by more than 200 million claims, claims the other two patients also are nearly two million.

It is learned that the three claims have more than one million patients, each patient was the admissibility of the court for a pre-case costs 2 million. At present, the patient's application, the court has agreed to a total of 3缓交the admissibility of 6 million yuan fee.

Zhao Wei, the payment he made the list from the hospital showed that in November 2005 to April this year, as a result of suffering from AIDS, hepatitis C and haemophilia exacerbations, Zhao son Chancheng hospital district spent a total of 580,000 yuan, So according to the standard 200,000 yuan each year, by upwards of Health confirmed that the recovery in 2001 from AIDS in 2009 until 8 years of treatment, for a total of 1.6 million.

In addition, he is also the spirit of solatium claim 100,000 yuan, "(infection) caused by AIDS to the spirit of combat, disease is a painful ordeal of ordinary people can not imagine. Destruction of the end, money can not be calculated." Zhao said the demands of their own not too much to ask.

100,000 yuan营养费, 210,000 yuan, such as disability living allowance is also to recover the list of Zhao Wei. Claim the other two patients with the same demands of the basic and Zhao Wei.

Foshan another eight by the use of Health and that the resulting factor of HIV-infected hemophiliacs Chen mother introduced similar cases across the country were put on nearly 10 cases, there are dozens of Friends of the blood of patients with HIV infection waiting, However, they make more use of the general grounds that the prosecution of personal injury compensation, and Foshan, the quality of products is based on three patients with the prosecution on the grounds of infringement.

Zhao said the November 28, 2008, Letters and Complaints Bureau in the Ministry of Health and the Health of the representations, the one on the Health of the internal staff in private that, on the Health of the 80's from the beginning of the last century the production of factor VIII, 1995 production, the total production and sales of more than 30 clotting factor 10,000, 50,000 more than the use of more than 300 known people living with HIV, the infection rate was 0.5%.

"You have to prove that the eight factors of production is no problem?" Said Chen, product liability personal injury caused by the implementation of the burden of proof that they only need to prove damage, without the need for physical damages as a general way, the patient the full burden of proof on to the existing Health fault, so the best interests of vulnerable patients.

Therefore, Chen said that she has asked for time on the Health of the raw materials used in the production of blood procurement have proved that the number of batches for the burden of proof. She also learned that the Health and the staff have privately admitted that their blood was the main point of procurement, mainly from Henan AIDS village, are large cans of refrigerated trucks to Latin America.

At the same time, she also called on the Health of the note to the judge, in the sign for the Ministry of Health No. 55, the "sales factor, the number eight? Sales where to go? Total number of eight-factor production, resulting in the same number of victims of domestic?"

Domino action

Since 2004, Friends of the National have blood in patients with HIV infection in the local prosecution by the Health, has been placed on file, but some cases by the court long. Of these, one patient in Shandong in 2004, the success of the local court file, and then sit

After March this year, Guangdong, Shandong, Jiangxi, Heilongjiang has nine provinces and cities in nearly 10 patients sue and file by the local court.

"Foshan to the case file, but also a gap away." Zhao said.

Before and after 1998, Shanghai, several of Health by the use of factor VIII and that the result of hemophiliacs infected with HIV, one after another to the Shanghai Changning District Court, claimed upwards of Health.

In 2003, these patients have received the court verdict Changning District. The court held that, in patients with a lack of sufficient evidence to prove that the HIV Health and produced by the "eight factor" There is a direct causal relationship, "but in view of the fact that the virus-infected persons for physical, mental caused tremendous damage and suffering "Health decree given on each patient" economic compensation "100,000 yuan.

And in October 2003, from Northeast China, Changsha, etc. A total of five hemophiliacs infected with AIDS, and will be prosecuted by the Health and deliver a petition the Court of Changning District, Shanghai, has been rejected. Since then, the country of such patients can not be a successful case in Shanghai.

However, since 2004, the National Friends of blood being HIV infected patients in the local prosecution by the Health, has been placed on file, but some cases by the court long. Of these, one patient in Shandong in 2004, the success of the local court file, and then sit, but so far no decision.

After March this year, Guangdong, Shandong, Jiangxi, Heilongjiang has nine provinces and cities in nearly 10 patients sue and file by the local court.

"We filed the lawsuit, by speaking on the Health, their heads hanging knife at all times." Zhao said.

Shanghai practice

Shanghai Municipal Government issued a unified policy to allow the Friends of the National blood of patients with HIV infection, with patients in Shanghai the same month will be 1000-3000 yuan to subsidize the lives of all treatment (including HIV complications) and the drug free of charge

July 2, with the prosecution of the Harbin Institute of Health and the proceedings were dismissed by the local court.

10 days, from Guangdong, Hunan, Shandong, Jiangxi and other places of the 5 patients with hemophilia infected with HIV families, emergency patients with the prosecution asked the mother of Harbin Zhao Xia (not her real name) to explore the merits of Changsha. Families of five patients in this litigation have been the present case the local court, anxiously waiting for trial or sentence.

Hu Harbin (a pseudonym), when 7-year-old, a traumatic bleeding diagnosed during hospitalization for hemophilia, and often spontaneous or minor traumatic hematoma when the limbs. In 1995, Zhao Xia two Shanghai Biological Products Institute to purchase the eight factors, and to the hospital for Hu injection. 3 years later, Hu infection by the detection of AIDS, rule out the possibility of infection and mother-to-child infection, the Hu-sheng considered by without the use of inactivated virus caused by the eight factors.

March 15 this year, Zhao Xia Hu agent as to the Harbin City, a district court filed a lawsuit demanding compensation Shanghai Institute of Biological Products for medical expenses and loss of fees to the cost of the spirit of nearly eight million yuan.

The case originally scheduled for July 1 in the trial, but in the end of June, the court hearing the sudden cancellation notice. July 2, the district court to inform Zhao Xia, said that the case is dismissed by the Court ruled that the prosecution.

The court held that the Department of Hu hemophiliacs infected with AIDS and the hepatitis C virus infection by a variety of ways, and China's Ministry of Health has been around for patients with AIDS and the medical treatment and living out relief issues the relevant policies, so the case should be public health policy to resolve dependencies. It is reported that Zhao Xia has ruled to the Court of Appeal in Harbin.






In recent years, HIV infection in patients with hemophilia and their families, many complaints to the Health of the Ministry of Health. (/ Figure Chen Zhigang photo)



"On the Health of the decision may have been faxed to the national courts of all the case," the patients from the families of Foshan in Guangdong Zhao said that if the court throughout the case to invoke such a determination, then a dozen places around the country stage of the proceedings of the patients are the families of all the efforts will have been in vain.

After two days of discussions, the families of six patients, will consider each case a comprehensive materials sent by Speedpost Supreme Court, the Supreme Procuratorate and the National People's Congress and ask for their attention and supervision of such cases.

"This award has been standing on my foot cliff, is the abyss beneath," Zhao Xia tears, she said that her son is currently the treatment of many of the drugs purchased abroad, so far pays the medical expenses of up to more than 550,000 yuan. The court ruled that in a few days ago, Hu could not bear the pain of suddenly running away from home, and found more than 10 days after his son, we had thin bones, he has been.

"First to protect his son's life, if his son had not only called for the death of upwards of Health award, we had to bear the pain and pay the cost of millions of treatment, who pays?" Zhao Foshan advised she said.

"We have an urgent need for a suitable treatment of hemophiliacs infected with HIV specialized rescue and life policies." Zhao said that although in 2003, the Government's AIDS the "Four Frees and One Care", by the Health and also to all parts of the country one after another Dozens of hemophiliacs infected with HIV to sign grant agreement, payment of 100,000 yuan per person, but at the same time suffering from hemophilia, AIDS, hepatitis C patients with various diseases is still only a drop in the bucket.

Many families of hemophiliacs infected with HIV, the countries in the existing combinations抗艾药free, some not suitable for patients with hemophilia, because of anti-HIV drugs on the liver is particularly serious side effects, a direct result of the the deterioration of liver disease. Coupled with low immune system, patients are often subject to a variety of complications, need for further treatment and testing.

From Foshan, Chen said, "infected with AIDS every year his son was hospitalized, medication, has been spending hundreds of thousands of their own expense, a one-time compensation of 100,000 yuan not enough."

Meeting in Changsha, the families of six patients told reporters that the claims in the proceedings at their own expense, the treatment of HIV infection after the hundreds of thousands or even millions of expenditure, they also called for the harmonization of policies introduced by the Government to allow national hemophilia patients infected with HIV, with the Shanghai patients with the same month will be the 1000-3000 yuan living allowance, treatment (including HIV complications) and the drug free of charge.

Since 2001, Shanghai to provide free AIDS treatment, and through the Red Cross, the city of many charitable organizations to raise funds for these patients given the difficulties of life grants, departments also carry out regular visits to help them solve their medical and living difficulties. (For understandable reasons, the text in the patients and their relatives are not his real name)

Hemophilia

Mankind's knowledge of hemophilia gene carrier females, through the genetic make the incidence of male offspring. Hemophiliacs due to a lack of normal clotting factor in vivo, and often more than bleeding, heavy bleeding patients are often spontaneous. The process of slow bleeding, lasting,巨痛, repeated joint bleeding site could eventually lead to muscle atrophy, motor dysfunction and permanently disabled, so far there is no way radical.

At present, worldwide about 40 million patients, my patients have at least 8-10 million, and is currently registered only in patients with more than 5,000 people, less than 5% of hemophilia patients treated hemophiliacs九成almost did not accept treatment norms.

Supplementary injection of various types of blood coagulation factor products is the only way to the treatment of hemophiliacs. And coagulation factors (mainly factor VIII) concentrates the production process of preparation is to thousands of plasma donors for the preparation of a mixture of packaging. As long as there is a plasma in which a virus, it will cause a large-scale infection.

Response

By the Health: AIDS treatment grants help state

3 patients in Foshan on the Health of the communication on behalf of, the other party has said that the country has been around for HIV-infected persons and patients with medical treatment and a living allowance introduced a policy on HIV-infected people and patients with relief of life issues, should be all over the coordination of relevant policies in accordance with the settlement of the country.

Patients: a national policy can not replace the local welfare businesses the responsibility of the incident

But this view has not been recognized in patients. "We enjoy a national policy and local benefits, the accident can not replace the responsibility of enterprises." Zhao said that the country's "Four Frees and One Care" policy for the provision of AIDS anti-retroviral therapy and other benefits, but there is no distinction between Is it because the infection caused by an act of the State, so the compensation is no substitute for policy.

Zhao said that in the Foshan city government's care policy, his son by the AIDS and hepatitis C infection has been the basic treatment, but the expenses for this year's maintenance treatment costs up to 20 million (not including the response to AIDS, hepatitis C anti - HIV treatment costs).

"My son has AIDS and hepatitis C infection is now in a state of morbidity, there is always fear life." Zhao Wei believes that his own HIV infection, subjected to physical and mental pain, is without the use of Health and by the elimination of live virus factor of eight, and the enjoyment of the national and local resources for the welfare of the people's livelihood, the rights of citizens, and not as an accident reduction by businesses on Health and the legal liability.

PK

In April this year, where the Health and Zhao Wei, who said he signed the grant agreement, the context of drug use in patients with hemophilia is complex, the use of whole blood, blood components, cryoprecipitate dissolved liquid source of a variety of blood products diverse, so the channels are also infected with HIV more than the actual infection is difficult to determine their own factor VIII production.

Patients: does not mix or other manufacturers products abroad

In response, Zhao Wei, Chen said the families of patients, such as Foshan, 1995 years ago, they only know on the Health of all the production and sale of "eight factor" products, the son has been using the Health of the eight factors, did not mix too foreign or other manufacturers of similar products.






(/ Figure Chen Zhigang photo)



House of the Friends of the Chinese have learned that before 1995, the domestic use of hemophiliacs is produced on the Health of the coagulation system factor VIII. At that time, "coagulation factor VIII" concentrate formulations of the production process, is different from thousands of donors for the plasma mixture preparation, packaging, in which a plasma as long as there is with HIV, it will cause a large-scale infection.

Questioned

By selling fake drugs on the Health?

After the suspension is issued by the Ministry of Health, the Health of the eight stocks are still many sales factor

Hemophiliacs small Zhao Bo's father said in the indictment, where the Health Ministry of Health license in 1991 was the production of clotting factor VIII approval, but without the removal of their products are to deal with viruses and inactivated.

July 20, 1995, the Ministry of Health issued an urgent text No. 55 "on the prohibition of production and clinical use without a virus removal or inactivation of blood coagulation factor products," which said sales of domestic product in the past, the blood clotting factor products, were not reliable after removal or inactivation of the virus. Application of such products there is a spread of blood-borne diseases (such as hepatitis B, hepatitis C, AIDS, etc.) at grave risk.

The reporter saw the document also demands that "all relevant units of blood products December 31, 1994 received the production of coagulation factor preparations Approval Number shall be void and immediately stop the production and marketing."

Zhao told reporters the sign for pieces of the production shows that the Health and by July 29 on receipt of the notice. "September 1995, November and December, operated by the Department of Health is still many times I sold stock to the eight factors." Zhao told reporters at the time produced more than one invoice.

In his view, where the sign on the Health Ministry of Health calls for an immediate halt to sales of 55 eight-factor after the text is still to sell their own factor VIII, "is in fact selling fake drugs to their own." It is learned that the State Food and Drug Administration will also be on of Health by July 1995 after 29 sales of the eight factors identified as counterfeit.

After the press access to the State Food and Drug Administration in 2007 the text on the 10th. Document said that after verification, to inform the Ministry of Health (No. 55) issued after the approval of National Drug sector to the Shanghai Institute of Biological Products for approval have been issued by the virus removal or inactivation of clotting factor produced products category Approval Number, "in violation of regulations if the production units to continue production, sale, punishable by fake drugs."

Zhao Wei also said that he is still well placed two bottles of unopened sold on the Health of the eight factors, including a bottle of the production date is July 1, 1993, to a large extent with the HIV virus, while a bottle of production date in 1995 February 1 is the State Food and Drug Administration found the fake drugs.

Zhao believes that the law on sale without a Health to remove the virus and inactivated factor VIII and von Willebrand nationwide are HIV-infected persons by the use of Health in 1994, 1995, the eight factors of production, they have reason to believe that AIDS is a son by the Health and the existence of the illegal sales of the product quality problems caused by infection, by request of Health held on Tort Liability of product quality.

Link

Abroad to compensate hemophiliacs infected with AIDS experience

Japan grants the spouse a monthly to a compensable

Japan's 1993 compensation package attractive. The program for all adult HIV-infected hemophiliacs, 2328 U.S. dollars per month to provide compensation. In addition, patients with von Willebrand disease due to AIDS-related hospitalization, the monthly 318 U.S. dollars to provide additional subsidies.

At the same time, Japan also provided pensions. Families lost their main labor force will be a period of 10 years, the monthly subsidy of 1575 U.S. dollars. If the main non-labor death, the family will receive a compensation of 63,257 U.S. dollars, as well as funeral expenses of the 1352 U.S. dollars.

In 1994, Japan's compensation program was revised to a spouse into the compensation scheme. The compensation fund by the Government of Japan and co-financed by pharmaceutical companies.

France awarded each additional 410,000 U.S. dollars

In 1989, the French government on grounds of blood products and infection of patients from 5298 to 30,088 U.S. dollars in compensation. At the same time, public solidarity fund - an insurance company specifically for HIV-infected hemophiliacs and their families to set up the fund, according to infection severity of the disease, the patient's age, the loss of income and family circumstances, to provide 5128 to 29,052 U.S. dollars in compensation.

When the evidence that the National Blood Transfusion Center, knowing that blood products may have been contaminated, but the distribution of these products will go extremely indignant public sentiment; At the same time, the face of rising medical costs, these funds can not meet the fundamental needs of the victim, facing France a large number of potential litigation. So France has established a new fund for the victims of a person up to an additional 417,377 U.S. dollars in compensation.

The United States paid 125,000 U.S. dollars a commitment not to prosecute patients

In March 1995, the U.S. House of Representatives submitted a RickyRay Hemophilia Relief Fund Act, which authorized the Government in 1980 to 1987 HIV-infected hemophiliacs and their family members to provide compensation. Lump sum compensation in the amount of 125,000 U.S. dollars, and patients receiving compensation promised not to prosecute the United States Food and Drug Administration. The bill was not until 2000 that sufficient funds will operate. (A quote from Asian Association for "Stones from other hills: the blood supply of international experience in dealing with pollution incidents")

(Editor: Chen Chao-ying)


1 2 3 4 Next

Source: online edition of Nanfang Dushi Bao Author: reporter Hai Yang Pengfei Chen Kai Chen